Is It Bad Luck to Grow Ivy Indoors?
The idea of growing ivy indoors often evokes its classic beauty, but for some, it also carries a hint of superstitious fear. Old English folklore suggests that ivy brought inside at the wrong time can attract misfortune, yet other traditions celebrate the vine as a symbol of fidelity and household protection. In modern times, the "luck" of an ivy plant is less about superstition and more about the practical realities of its care—balancing its benefits against its challenges.
The Roots of Superstition: A Harbinger of Misfortune?
The belief that indoor ivy is a harbinger of bad luck is primarily rooted in European folklore, stemming from several key ideas:
- Association with Death and Decay: Ivy is frequently seen growing on old ruins and gravestones. This connection to mortality and decay led to the belief that bringing it inside would invite a similar fate, with some traditions suggesting it foretold an imminent death in the family.
- A Matter of Timing: A persistent belief in English folklore is that it's unlucky to bring ivy indoors at any time of the year except during the Christmas season. If ivy brought in at other times withered, it was seen as a sign of disaster.
- Financial Hardship: Another superstition suggests that having ivy grow in the house invites financial trouble and poverty.
- Pagan Connections: Before its adoption by Christianity, ivy was a significant symbol in pagan rituals, particularly those for Dionysus (Greek god of wine) and Bacchus (his Roman counterpart). As Christianity spread, many pagan symbols were re-cast as negative, and ivy's association with "heathen" practices may have led to it being considered unlucky in a Christian home.
- Connection to the Fae: Because ivy grown outdoors is often considered a protective charm, one theory suggests taking it from its natural woodland environment—believed to be home to fairies—is akin to stealing and could anger them.
A Symbol of Protection, Fidelity, and Resilience
Contrary to the superstitions, ivy has a rich history of positive symbolism across many cultures, often representing strength, connection, and eternal life.
| Symbol | Cultural Context & Meaning |
|---|---|
| Fidelity, Love & Marriage | In ancient Greece and Rome, ivy wreaths were given to newlyweds to symbolize the strength and eternal nature of their bond. During the Victorian era, its clinging habit made it a popular motif in mourning jewelry to represent loyalty even after death. |
| Protection & Good Luck | Growing ivy up the outside walls of a house was believed to protect its inhabitants from misfortune and evil spirits. Celtic and Druid lore viewed it as a living guardian, not a curse. |
| Eternal Life & Immortality | As an evergreen plant that stays vibrant through winter, ivy came to symbolize resurrection and the eternal soul in Christian belief. In ancient Egypt, it was dedicated to Osiris, the god of immortality. |
| Achievement & Resilience | Ivy's ability to thrive in harsh conditions symbolizes determination and survival. It was used to crown victorious athletes in ancient Greece and scholars in Rome, linking the vine to achievement. |
| Christmas Tradition | Bringing holly and ivy indoors at Christmas is a long-standing tradition. In some customs, ivy represents the feminine principle, balancing the masculine principle of holly. |
Modern Interpretations: Feng Shui
In modern home practices, ivy has found a positive place in Feng Shui. Its energy, or zhen qi, is considered protective and boundary-setting. Practitioners often recommend placing English ivy near doors or in room corners to establish a sense of security. However, they also advise regular pruning to ensure its qi does not become stagnant or "overgrown," which could block positive energy flow.
The Practical Guide to Growing Ivy Indoors
Beyond folklore, the tangible benefits and drawbacks of growing ivy have a much greater impact on your household than any perceived luck.
Benefits of Indoor Ivy
- Air Purification: Ivy is famously recognized by NASA's Clean Air Study for its ability to filter airborne toxins. It can help reduce levels of harmful volatile organic compounds (VOCs) like benzene, formaldehyde, xylene, and toluene, contributing to a healthier indoor environment.
- Aesthetic Appeal: With its lush foliage and cascading vines, ivy adds classic elegance to any space. It is versatile and can be grown in hanging baskets, displayed on shelves, or trained to climb.
- Humidity Regulation: Ivy has a naturally high transpiration rate, meaning it releases moisture into the air, which can help increase humidity levels in a dry room.
Challenges and Care Considerations
While often considered low-maintenance, ivy requires specific care to thrive and can present several challenges.
- Toxicity: All parts of the English ivy plant are toxic to pets and humans if ingested. The leaves contain saponins that can cause vomiting, drooling, abdominal pain, and diarrhea in cats and dogs. Contact with the sap can also cause a skin rash in sensitive individuals, so it's best to keep the plant out of reach of children and pets and wear gloves when pruning.
- Rapid Growth: Ivy is a vigorous grower. If left unchecked, its vines can tangle in vents, damage woodwork, and crack paint, leading to real-world "bad luck" in the form of repair bills. Regular pruning is essential to keep it contained.
| Problem | Cause | Solution |
|---|---|---|
| Pest Infestations (Spider Mites, Aphids) | Pests are often attracted to the warm, dry conditions common in heated homes, especially during winter. | Increase humidity by misting the plant. Periodically wash the leaves with water, and treat infestations with insecticidal soap or neem oil. |
| Root Rot | Overwatering or pots with poor drainage leave the soil soggy, causing the roots to rot. | Water thoroughly only when the top inch of soil is dry to the touch. Ensure the pot has drainage holes. |
| Leaf Discoloration | Brown leaves often indicate overwatering. Yellow leaves can mean too much direct sunlight. Variegated varieties may lose their distinctive coloring in low-light conditions. | Adjust your watering schedule. Move the plant to a location that receives bright, indirect light. |
Conclusion: A Matter of Perspective
So, is it bad luck to grow ivy indoors? The superstition is rooted in ancient folklore, but for every negative connotation, there is a positive one celebrating ivy as a symbol of fidelity, resilience, and protection. In a modern home, the plant's "luck" is determined by the practical realities of its care.
A healthy, thriving ivy can purify the air and add natural beauty, which many would consider very good fortune. Conversely, a pest-infested, improperly placed, or neglected plant can create real problems. Ultimately, the decision to grow ivy indoors comes down to personal belief and a willingness to provide the proper care it needs to flourish.
Works Cited
- Anna Franklin, “English Ivy – Hearth Witchery.”
- Artefacts-Collector, "Symbolism/Ivy."
- Art of Mourning, “Symbolism Sunday: Ivy.”
- ASPCApro, “17 Plants Poisonous to Pets – English Ivy.”
- Bellabeat, "The Story Of Ivy."
- Better Homes & Gardens, “How to Plant and Grow English Ivy.”
- BloomingBox, "5 Surprising Benefits of Variegated English Ivy..."
- Clemson University Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, "Growing English Ivy Indoors."
- Costa Farms, "Plant Rx: 5 Tips for Raising English Ivy Indoors."
- Druid Tree Lore, “English Ivy.” druidry.org.
- EyeFeather.com, "Ivy Plant Spiritual Meaning and Symbolism."
- Gardening Know How, "Ivy Houseplants."
- Green Plants for Green Buildings, “A Superhero Scrubs the Air: English Ivy.”
- Healthline, “5 Fast Facts About English Ivy.”
- House Beautiful, “17 Feng Shui Plants.”
- Icy Sedgwick, “The Folklore of Ivy.”
- MagicBricks, "English Ivy Plant."
- Maple Ridge-Pitt Meadows News, “My List of Superstitious Plants.”
- Molekule, “Do English Ivy Plants Improve Air Quality?”
- NASA, “Interior Landscape Plants for Indoor Air-Pollution Abatement.”
- Otherworldly Oracle, "Is it bad luck to grow ivy indoors?"
- PictureThis AI, “English Ivy Care” and “Where to Place English Ivy in Feng Shui?”
- Plant-Lore Archive, “Survey of ‘Unlucky’ Plants.”
- Plants & Flowers Foundation, "Ivy."
- Quora, "Is having ivy indoors actually bad luck..."
- Royal Horticultural Society, "Ivy: grow guide."
- The Second Hand Jewellery Box, “Victorian Symbols of Devotion – Ivy.”
- Southern Living, "How To Grow And Care For Ivy Plants Indoors."
- Travel France Online, "Ivy Christmas Plants."
- Ugaoo, "English Ivy Indoor Plant: Easy Care, Big Benefits."